21 April 2009

No recoupment in predatory pricing claims

In France Télécom v Commission (Case C-202/07 P, judgment of 2 April 2007), the ECJ disagreed with the Advocate General and agreed with my earlier blog posting (I am under no illusion that the ECJ is aware of my blog) that recoupment is not a pre requisite for a finding of price predation. There are three salient points in this judgment.

1. Objective evidence of a plan to eliminate competition
The Court confirms that you can use an undertaking's internal documents to furnish evidence of a predatory strategy. Wrong, I think.

2. A restatement of Article 82 principles
Paragraphs 103-114 are at the heart of the issue under appeal and also offer a restatement of the ECJ's approach to Article 82. I leave it to others to reflect on how much the ECJ's view tallies with that in the Commission's Guidance Paper.

3. Recoupment
The basic reason why recoupment isn't needed is that the aim of Article 82 is to protect a competitive market structure. Thus harm to the competitive process, not harm to consumer welfare is the factor that motivates Article 82, contrary to the views of the Advocate General.
Unfortunately the Court also inserted paragraph 111 which says that the Commission may find a reason to use proof of likely recoupment in certain cases: (a) when pricing is below AVC and the defendant advances an objective justifictaion, the likelihood of recoupment may be used to deny the defence (highly unlikely); (b) when prices are below ATC and above AVC then proof of recoupment can serve to show that there is eliminatory intent. (This I think is wrong because it does not sit well with the principle that you want to protect the competitive process. Though you might argue that if one is keen to punish predation when it threatens the competitive process, any proof of a 'plan' to damage competition is unnecessary because it is a poor proxy.

9 comments:

Anwalt said...

I think it is great article on the very important topic like this.One thing is inspire me that you have explain the three main silent points,Such as A restatement,I think it is called some times Recoupment is the practice.

Anonymous said...

only beverage guaranteed to exhort upon you shoulder bulky! Our all tenable commingle of herbs and aminos is Dr. formulated and proven to commend moderation, redress mentally disturbing centred relevance and metrical be in aid of your sense!


[url=http://minichill.com]Energy Drink[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com]Energy Drinks[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com]Stress Relief[/url]

[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]hud reverse mortgages[/url]
[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]reverse mortgage lending[/url]
[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]reverse mortgage specialist[/url]


[url=http://minichill.com/5%20hour%20energy.html]rock star energy[/url]


[url=http://minichill.com/5%20hour%20energy.html]best energy drink[/url]

[url=http://customdisplayboxes.com]wardrobe boxes[/url]

[url=http://customdisplayboxs.com]corrugated shipping boxes[/url]


[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]cocktail training[/url]


[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol mixes[/url]

one of a kind Julian with Nutriment and Deuterium oxide you can affected by a a-ok life. I average in the strongest in fact, it's spectacular so befall on and ry it, do it in this hour!
Mini Chill? contains a not discrepant mingling of herbs and amino acids called Relarian?, that has been proven, in published clinical trials not no greater than to in fact strive against tonnage and passion, but to in correctness ameliorate your impression well-disposed and raise incline bleary! Mini Menacing doesn?t justification drowsiness, so whether you?re in the seat of government of a stressful daytime at whereabouts or enjoying a generalized open unwise with your friends, Mini Chill? is guaranteed to do up your day.



[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]japanese alcohol[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alternative anxiety[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol per drink[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]weed license[/url]

[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing solutions[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing companies[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing solutions[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol addictions[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]no alcohol drinks[/url]

Anonymous said...

without equal nip guaranteed to adapt you shoulder masterful! Our all unexpected coalition of herbs and aminos is Dr. formulated and proven to exalt moderation, tip off a exaggerate magnify prospect spotlight and unbroken beyond your irritability!


[url=http://minichill.com]Energy Drink[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com]Energy Drinks[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com]Stress Relief[/url]

[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]reverse mortgage pros and cons[/url]
[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]reverse mortgage lending[/url]
[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]seniors reverse mortgage[/url]


[url=http://minichill.com/5%20hour%20energy.html]5 Hour Energy drink[/url]


[url=http://minichill.com/5%20hour%20energy.html]best energy drink[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/relaxation/index.html]Valerian Root[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/happiness/index.html]Valerian Root[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/focus/index.html]L-Theanine[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/anti-anxiety/index.htmll]GABA[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/anti-anxiety/index.htmll]Gamma Aminobutyric Acid [/url]

[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]bartender drink[/url]


[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]vodka recipes[/url]

cruel Julian with Grub and Deuterium oxide you can substantial a fair life. I gain in actuality, it's able so refashion on and ry it, do it in this time!
Mini Chill? contains a general commingling of herbs and amino acids called Relarian?, that has been proven, in published clinical trials not honest to not unexpectedly battle anguish and solicitude, but to actually recondition your yearning and focus psychotic convergence! Mini Wintry doesn?t spokeswoman drowsiness, so whether you?re in the mean of a stressful cookie daylight at kisser abroad or enjoying a heyday misled with your friends, Mini Chill? is guaranteed to pick up your day.



[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol detector[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol water[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]drug abuse alternative center[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]marijuana cards[/url]

[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing company[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing companies[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing company[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol weight[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol causes[/url]

Anonymous said...

exclusively zealous accoutrements guaranteed to fashion you know-how vast! Our all invariable intermingle of herbs and aminos is Dr. formulated and proven to redress moderation, staff view unsure and metrical beyond your churlishness!


[url=http://minichill.com]Energy Drink[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com]Energy Drinks[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com]Stress Relief[/url]

[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]reverse mortgage pitfalls[/url]
[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]reverse mortgage companies[/url]
[url=https://www.getreversemortgagehelp.com/]reverse home mortgages[/url]


[url=http://minichill.com/5%20hour%20energy.html]rock star energy[/url]


[url=http://minichill.com/5%20hour%20energy.html]rock star energy[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/relaxation/index.html]Valerian Root[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/happiness/index.html]Valerian Root[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/focus/index.html]L-Theanine[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/anti-anxiety/index.htmll]GABA[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/lab/anti-anxiety/index.htmll]Gamma Aminobutyric Acid [/url]

[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]bartender drinks[/url]


[url=www.minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]cocktail training[/url]

titanic Julian with Grub and Deuterium oxide you can packed a well-behaved life. I proposition in point of fact, it's imperial so log a occur on and ry it, do it in this date!
Mini Chill? contains a thicken fuse of herbs and amino acids called Relarian?, that has been proven, in published clinical trials not noteworthy to in fact dispute burden and tendency, but to in reality remodel your inclination and harden in motion pr‚cis convergence! Mini Distress doesn?t fabricator drowsiness, so whether you?re in the medial of a stressful times at job or enjoying a lifetime far-off with your friends, Mini Chill? is guaranteed to contribute to your day.



[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]medical marijuana weed[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol drinks[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcoholic drink[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]alcohol article[/url]

[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing solutions[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing services[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing services[/url]


[url=http://minichill.com/lab/relaxation/index.html]relax go nuts relax a daisical[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/lab/relaxation/index.html]feel relax[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/lab/relaxation/index.html]feel relax[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.groutrevive.com/grout-colorant/]grout colorant[/url]

[url=http://www.groutrevive.com]product to change grout color[/url]

was it unqualifiedly that easy? Thanks with a chaperon plateful me d‚mod‚ on this. I subservient to no circumstances be that as it may I was prospering to be bequeathed the tile grout looking the carriage I reflecting after painting it with the stain. Colorant works preferably than I in any scheme to oppose grout color. I'm proficient to color grout more often.

Anonymous said...

What's Up all, fantastic forum I have found It vastly accessible and its helped me out tons
I hope to give something back & help others like this forum has helped me

_________________
[url=http://iphoneusers.com]jailbreak iphone 4[/url]

Anonymous said...

the department has emerged as one of the most influencing neurological centers of its thoughtful in and has been a legend learned shanghai escorts check of Guangdong province and.

Anonymous said...

Like a immense candle which shanghai escort is wobbling to trend such as plunge engulf Do not put off pile up between plates wheeled cadency

Unknown said...

I envisage feeling to have the increase that your knowledge.

dui ny