26 September 2008

France Telecom judgment in peril?

Advocate Ganeral Mazák has issued a call for less aggressive use of predatory pricing in his Opinion of 25 September 2008 relating to the Wanadoo decision where the Commission found that the appellant charged predatory prices below variable costs (AVC) until August 2001, and above AVC but below average total cost (ATC) from August 2001 onwards, as part of a plan to pre-empt the market in high-speed internet access during a key phase in its development. However, I think his views should not be followed by the ECJ.

Essentially the appellant won on three grounds:
1) CFI failed to state reasons when commenting on a dominant firm's right to align prices
2) CFI falied to state reasons why recoupment need not be shown
3) Likely recoupment must be demonstrated by the Commission in predatory pricing cases

In addition the AG also said that in his view a dominant firm should, on occasion, be allowed to align its prices with those of competitors.

Each of these four conclusions can be criticised.

1) Failure to state reasons regarding the dominant firm's right to align prices to competitors.
The passage of the CFI under appeal is this: "WIN cannot therefore rely on an absolute right to align its prices on those of its competitors in order to justify its conduct. Even if alignment of prices by a dominant undertaking on those of its competitors is not in itself abusive or objectionable, it might become so where it is aimed not only at protecting its interests but also at strengthening and abusing its dominant position." [187]

The AG's criticism was scathing because the CFI did not apply this paragraph to the facts at hand. In his words the CFI "should therefore have assessed whether or not that (new) formulation applied to the facts in the instant case, something which it manifestly did not do." [49]
With respect, this is wrong. Look at the passage in bold above and the facts of the case. On the facts of the case the CFI ruled that the firm's condct was predatory (below AVC for a period and between AVC and ATC with intention for another period). Therefore the pricing fell squarely withing AKZO [71 and 72]. So the behaviour is in itself abusive. Accordingly there was no need for the CFI to assess the formulation. It is merely an obiter dicta as to what the law is.

2) Failure to state reasons about recoupment
Here the AG notes that in Tetra Pak 2 the ECJ held that proof of likely recoupment was unnecessary "in the circumstances of that particular case" and criticises the CFI for not expaining whether there are also circumstances in this case that allow a finding of predatory pricing without recoupment. [58-60 of the Opinion]
This is a plausible line of attack, but another view can be taken of what the CFI said. It is worth quoting the CFI in France Telecom at length:
226 In relation to the recoupment of losses, the Court of Justice (in Tetra Pak 2) added, in paragraph 44 of that judgment: ‘[I]t would not be appropriate, in the circumstances of the present case, to require in addition proof that Tetra Pak had a realistic chance of recouping its losses. It must be possible to penalise predatory pricing whenever there is a risk that competitors will be eliminated. The Court of First Instance found, at paragraphs 151 and 191 of its judgment, that there was such a risk in this case. The aim pursued, which is to maintain undistorted competition, rules out waiting until such a strategy leads to the actual elimination of competitors.’
227 In line with Community case-law, the Commission was therefore able to regard as abusive prices below average variable costs. In that case, the eliminatory nature of such pricing is presumed. In relation to full costs, the Commission had also to provide evidence that WIN’s predatory pricing formed part of a plan to ‘pre-empt’ the market. In the two situations, it was not necessary to establish in addition proof that WIN had a realistic chance of recouping its losses.

So the reason why in Tetra Pak 2 proof of likely recoupment was unnecessary was because the Commission had proved that there was a risk that a competitor would be eliminated. This means that the risk that a competitor would be eliminated by predatory pricing one relevant circumstance when proof of likely recoupment is unnecessary. And at [227] the CFI gives reasons in conformity with this because the facts showed that the competitor was put at risk.

Of course you can argue that this is a bad reason. It is bad because it means that as soon as you satisfy the conditions set out in AKZO [71 or 72] then you have shown a risk of elimination and so you never need recoupment. But then perhaps this is what AKZO actually stands for (see below)

3) Likely recoupment in predatory pricing cases
This point is the most relevant for future cases. The AG takes the view that "case-law requires the possibility of recoupment of losses to be proven." [69] The reasoning is based on the fact that because the ECJ in Tetra Pak 2 said that proof of likely recoupment was unnecessary on the facts of that case, that it must mean that as a general rule proof of likely recoupment is necessary.
I think this is wrong. The bold part of para 44 of Tetra Pak 2 (see above) tells you that the rationale for penalising predtory pricing is to avoid the risk that a competitor is eliminated. Therefore whether the dominant company recoups or not is unnecessary, it is the risk to competitors that is the Court's concern.

The AG says that proof of likely recoupmet is supported by AKZO [71]. Let us consider this passage in full:
"Prices below average variable costs (that is to say, those which vary depending on the quantities produced) by means of which a dominant undertaking seeks to eliminate a competitor must be regarded as abusive. A dominant undertaking has no interest in applying such prices except that of eliminating competitors so as to enable it subsequently to raise its prices by taking advantage of its monopolistic position, since each sale generates a loss, namely the total amount of the fixed costs (that is to say, those which remain constant regardless of the quantities produced) and, at least, part of the variable costs relating to the unit produced. "

The passage in bold would seem to me to indicate that there is a presumption that recoupment is likely if a firm prices below cost. A presumption that does not therefore require the Commission to show likley recoupment. But, perhaps, a presumption that may be rebutted by the dominant firm who could try and say that recoupment is unlikely because, for example, it is selling off old stock.

Nor does Hoffmann La Roche [91] support the necessity of recoupment, quite the opposite: it supports a finding of abuse whenever the degree of competition in the market is hindered. This occurs once the rival leaves.

One can however feel for the AG because he aligns himself with the views of AG Jacobs in Bronner that the purpose of Art 82 is to protect consumers, not individual competitors. However not all Advocates General believe this (see AG Kokott for instance).

4) Price alignment by a dominant firm
Should a dominant firm be entitle dto align its prices with those of competitors? The plea is inadmissible, but the AG suggests that "one should allow for circumstances where a dominant undertaking is exceptionally permitted to show that its pricing below average variable cost is objectively justified. " [95]
True, most commentators would say that one such circumstance is when the dominant firm is selling off old stock. The difficult question is whether the dominant firm should do this when it is doing so with the clear intention of damaging a new entrant in a market where it was the incumbent for many years.

Summary
The AG is calling for a major change in the law on below cost pricing, by placing a greater focus on the impact on consumer welfare and less on the economic freedom of market participants. The problem is that the case law which seemingly creates the basis for this shift does not support it. AKZO and Tetra Pak 2 are clearly cases where the dominant concern is the preservation of rivalry, of a competitive process. The radical change called for here should be made by advising the Court to change its approach rather than by asking the court to reinterpret its case law.

I hope the ECJ does not follow the AG on the first two points, the CFI gave reasons that can be understood. That they are bad reasons is another matter, so perhaps the ECJ could require proof of likely recoupment. Though it might want to note that the requirement to show this in the US has led to no successfu predatory pricing prosecution as far as I know. Is the ECJ so Chicagoan to want this result?

56 comments:

Priscila Brolio said...

It's very good to know that the antitrust community is not (yet) completely dominated by ultra-liberal views, which (as you mentioned) make impossible the application of penalties to dominant companies that adopt predatory pricing (to eliminate rivals or to prevent new entries in a relevant market) or other exclusionary behaviour. In Brazil, a predatory pricing case related to the oil industry has recently been shelved, among other reasons, because the plaintiff wasn't able to demonstrate the likeliness of recoupment. This particular argument was very surprising to me, since the rivals of the incumbent had already interrupted their activities in that particular market (allegedly, because of predatory pricing and margin squeeze). In other words, competitors had actually been eliminated from the market. Still, the argument that antitrust enforcement is exclusively for consumers' (and not competitors') benefit prevailed. And since nobody could mathematically demonstrate that the incumbent would be able to raise prices and exploit consumers in the future, the requirements for the continuing of the investigations were considered not to be fulfilled. I belive that such an argument ("consumers versus competitors") is falacious, specially when applied in cases as the one described by you, to stop legitimate investigations involving incontestably dominant firms (in some cases, monopolies)' behaviour. To me it is difficult to see a concrete conflict between consumers and competitors interests in cases like this. In the end of the day, both benefit from competition. Of course this is a personal conviction, based on philosophical beliefs which, unfortunatelly, seem to be disappearing in the "antitrust world". In a time when everybody speaks about convergence, I sincerelly hope Europe will keep on differentiating itself from the rest of the world. "Toda unanimidade é burra", a Brazilian famous writer once said.

Rgp, said...

Soy Ronald Gonzales peruano de nacimiento. Te escribo para comunicarte que en Lima estamos totalmente indignados con los comentarios denigrantes y absurdos del comandante general del Ejército,Edwin Donayre, por sus bajos comentarios cargados de xenofobia.

En mi opinión no debió lanzar esas estupideces y te pido que no cortes a todos los peruanos con la misma tijera.

Saludos y anexo mi mail por si deseas comunicarte conmigo. También sigo periodismo y sería fortuito crear un lazo mediante nuestros blogs.

Chao
Rgp.
http://actuaciudadano.blogspot.com/

Mattia De Biasi said...

Hi! I just wanted to mention an interesting point about predatory pricing I read in a paper by Ferrari Bravo and Siciliani, about why dominance is not a sufficient substitute for recoupment. They point out an inverse cellophane fallacy in the sense that the SSNIP test will delimitate a too narrow market because the starting point of the test is a level of prices that is already very low. In that sense, a firm might be deemed dominant (and liable for art.82 abuse) even if it faces demand substitutes that constrain its ability to recoup.

Anonymous said...

Good day
This simply remarkable message
[url=http://mercedese.4sql.net/87/map.html]mercedes replica alloys map 16[/url]

Total good

Anonymous said...

Hallo everybody!
It was specially registered at a forum to tell to you thanks for support.
[url=http://mercedes.20ehost.com/85/index.html]mercedes ride pony p[/url]


See you soon

Anonymous said...

I am glad to see you all
What for mad thought?
[url=http://forkliifte.my-place.us/05/index.html]nissan forklift enduro r[/url]

Bye

Anonymous said...

I really liked you
What entertaining phrase
[url=http://mercedes.260mb.com/101/map.html]wis asra mercedes map r[/url]

Total good

Anonymous said...

you here bad
I apologise, but it not absolutely approaches me. Perhaps there are still variants?
[url=http://carrentals.x50.cc/bos/41/index.html]diy trailers bicycle c[/url]

See you later

Anonymous said...

welcome
It is remarkable, very good piece
[url=http://therapy.vergilhost.info/61/index.html]epilepsy temporal lobe Q[/url]

We will be glad to see you

Anonymous said...

visit, not regret
I consider, that you are not right. Let's discuss it. Write to me in PM, we will talk.
[url=http://detrol.0adz.com/code/45/index.html]for detoxifying products E[/url]

Total good

Anonymous said...

Hallo everybody!
I can not take part now in discussion - there is no free time. Very soon I will necessarily express the opinion.
[url=http://mercedes.byethost3.com/77/map.html]laceby mercedes map c[/url]

G'night

Anonymous said...

Good morning
You are not right. Write to me in PM, we will discuss.
[URL=http://genital-herpes.actorsite.com/dmso/index.html]Learn more dmso cream for herpes[/URL]

See you later

Anonymous said...

All of the high-level
What do you advise to me?
[url=http://mercedes.corefreehosting.com.ar/mer59/map.html]trieda mercedes c map L[/url]

We will not miss you

Anonymous said...

Top Internet sites
I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are not right. I am assured. I can defend the position. Write to me in PM, we will discuss.
[url=http://agglutinin.xoom.it/42/map.html]depaul university paralegal map 809[/url]

We are waiting for you

Anonymous said...

Hi all!
Good gradually.
[url=http://military.0fees.net/mil10/map.html]arminian military helicopters map 251[/url]

We will not miss you

Anonymous said...

Good morning
Takes a bad turn.
[url=http://bahill.edafa.info/56/index.html] mjl trailers S[/url]

Go to the guests

Anonymous said...

web sites websites
Whence to me the nobility?
[url=http://atrovent.h.gp/162/map.html]natural substitute viagra j[/url]


See you soon

Anonymous said...

Hi all!
Completely I share your opinion. In it something is also I think, what is it excellent idea.
[url=http://dysfunction.t.gp/in/62/index.html]exercise induced preventing b[/url]

Total good

Anonymous said...

design super!
In it something is. Now all is clear, many thanks for the information.
[url=http://hives.gb.nf/63/map.html]urticarial emedicine vasculitis h[/url]

Go to the guests

Anonymous said...

Hello
In my opinion you commit an error. I can defend the position.
[url=http://treatment.detailed.de/33/index.html]suppressant bronchitis cough F[/url]

Total good

Anonymous said...

excellent design
I consider, that you commit an error. I can defend the position. Write to me in PM.
[url=http://military.4sql.net/mil105/map.html]military vmi virginia map G[/url]


See you soon

Anonymous said...

Good evening
Between us speaking the answer to your question I have found in google.com
[url=http://freecasino.kohost.0lx.net/for/49/map.html]troubleshooting toyota forklift map K[/url]

See you later

Anonymous said...

I liked the look in again
You were not mistaken
[url=http://forklift.phpnet.us/for06/map.html]enduro forklift nissan b[/url]

We are waiting for you

Anonymous said...

hi all!nice world
best

Anonymous said...

fascinating conversation
You commit an error. Let's discuss.
[url=http://mercedes.edafa.info/mer25/index.html]mercedes 25000 nail 967[/url]

Total good

Anonymous said...

welcome
I join told all above. We can communicate on this theme.
[url=http://bags.phpnet.us/62/map.html]rate private fixed map p[/url]

Bye

Anonymous said...

Good evening
In it something is also idea good, I support.
[URL=http://qobovoc.angelfire.com/and/map.html]viagra and reduced immunity[/URL]

G'night

Anonymous said...

Hallo everybody!
I apologise, but, in my opinion, you are mistaken. I can defend the position.
[url=http://forklift.summerhost.info/for22/index.html]rtitb forklift n[/url]

We are waiting for you

Anonymous said...

design super!
It is remarkable, very amusing piece
[url=http://buyalesse.niigakirisa.org/code/64/map.html]of drug facts map o[/url]

Welcome

Anonymous said...

All good health!
The matchless message, is pleasant to me :)
[url=http://mercedes.enterneted.com/mer09/index.html]y el alfonsina g[/url]

Good luck

Anonymous said...

you here bad
The useful message
[url=http://helmar.my-php.net/59/map.html]refinance auto low map n[/url]

Good luck

Anonymous said...

Good day
In it something is. I agree with you, thanks for an explanation. As always all ingenious is simple.
[url=http://forklift.xtreemhost.com/for07/index.html]forklift check sheet 477[/url]

We will not miss you

Anonymous said...

Thank you, that was extremely valuable and interesting...I will be back again to read more on this topic.

Anonymous said...

unequalled tipple guaranteed to construction you convoy countless! Our all earnest commingle of herbs and aminos is Dr. formulated and proven to revolt differentiate, redress slant centralized moment and unchanging endorse your jocularity!



[url=http://minichill.com/Enhancer.html]best penis enlargement pills[/url]


rare Julian with Comestibles and D you can unexploded a well-behaved life. I access indeed, it's horrifying so refashion on and ry it, do it now!
Mini Chill? contains a realistic grade of herbs and amino acids called Relarian?, that has been proven, in published clinical trials not only to superfluous to turn contend against spoilsport and angst, but to in actuality refashion your eager and fare well bend into! Mini Aloofness doesn?t justification drowsiness, so whether you?re in the medial of a stressful daytime at mien at large or enjoying a plain obscure of age unapproachable with your friends, Mini Chill? is guaranteed to improve your day.



[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]stop smoking weed[/url]

[url=http://minichill.com/ChillRecipes.html]marijuana brownies[/url]


[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing companies[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing outsourcing[/url]
[url=http://www.finmedsys.com/]medical billing services[/url]


[url=http://www.seoimpressions.com/]seo training[/url]
[url=http://www.seoimpressions.com/]seo optimization[/url]
[url=http://www.seoimpressions.com/]search engine optimization tips[/url]
[url=http://www.seoimpressions.com/]seo company uk[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/Enhancer.html]erectile dysfunction prostate[/url]
[url=http://minichill.com/Enhancer.html]erectile dysfunction ed[/url]

Anonymous said...

scariest movie ever http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_station_agent/ the brave one the movie jodie foster [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_what_s_new_pussycat/]what s new pussycat[/url]
reconciliation movie theme film http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_serving_in_silence_the_margarethe_cammermeyer_story/ upload sex movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/hqmoviesbygenres/download-genre_documentary-movies/?page=5]gypsy caravan movie[/url]
latets movie trailers http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_night_we_called_it_a_day/ hindi movie songs [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_recruit/]the recruit[/url]
free bdsm movie clips http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_halloween_70/ bruce willis movie the kid [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_jennifer/]twilight the movie[/url]
kodak brownie 300 movie projector http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_d_war/ blood movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_life_on_mars/]life on mars[/url]
ballet shoes movie emma watson http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_one_way/ miss russia 2006 porn movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_lac_des_morts_vivants_le/]linsey dawn mckenzie movie trailers[/url]

Anonymous said...

forex online tested and reviewed by expert traders Realize exactly what is most effective and exactly what doesnt along with foreign currency trading expert critiques and analysis of the up-to-date automations [URL=http://www.forexrobot.tv]forexrobot.tv[/URL].

We find out about the real truth forex trading bots and also indicate to the unsuspicious consumer everything that seriously matter check it out online forex trading reviews Uncover precisely what is most effective and everything that does not by way of foreign exchange [URL=http://www.forexrobot.tv]forex trading strategies[/URL]

Anonymous said...

[URL=http://autoruni.freehostia.com/]welcome auto insurances...[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing the link, but unfortunately it seems to be down... Does anybody have a mirror or another source? Please answer to my message if you do!

I would appreciate if someone here at competitionlawboard.blogspot.com could post it.

Thanks,
Thomas

Anonymous said...

Hello !

I'm new on this forum so I introduce me...

My name is Jason I'm 23 years old, I'm Spanish.

I like: holdem poker and kitesurf...

Nice to meet you

Anonymous said...

nurse travel breech of contract http://icej.eu/home/modern-home-building cheapest air travel world cruises [url=http://icej.eu/siding/shak-vinyl-siding]shak vinyl siding[/url]
canada refugee travel loan repayment http://icej.eu/moving/moving-faces rv travel on california 101 [url=http://icej.eu/bathrooms/are-there-ant-bathrooms]power adapter travel[/url]
travel now of menominie http://icej.eu/window/ford-2007-rear-window venere travel [url=http://icej.eu/home/polaris-home-page]polaris home page[/url]
travel advisories for ontario http://icej.eu/floor/fire-alarm-system-design-floor-plan travel insurances [url=http://icej.eu/bathrooms/are-there-ant-bathrooms]graco snugride laura ashley canterbury travel system recalled[/url]
travel in monaghan http://icej.eu/decorations/minnie-mouse-cake-decorations woolrich travel vest [url=http://icej.eu/window/integrity-window-finish]integrity window finish[/url]
travel shots for canadians http://icej.eu/decoration/mehndi-stage-decoration-designs jet travel video [url=http://icej.eu/landscaping/hermes-landscaping]north carolina travel brochures[/url]

Anonymous said...

pre existing medical condition travel insurance http://uhas.eu/cell-phone-reviews/free-phone-dating-service punta cana travel destinations [url=http://uhas.eu/cell-phone-directory/mature-women-phone-sex]mature women phone sex[/url]
nationwide travel insurance http://uhas.eu/mobile-world/oawasys-mobile-phone-manual navigator travel center inc [url=http://uhas.eu/mobile-world/my-mobile-proxy-server-port-no-details]illinois travel[/url]
train travel paris london cheap fare http://uhas.eu/search-mobile/prophet-touch-windows-mobile-6-xda-neo personal air travel [url=http://uhas.eu/cell-phone-reviews/what-is-the-phone-number-and-email-adress-to-cantact-the-fcc]what is the phone number and email adress to cantact the fcc[/url]
corpus christi travel http://uhas.eu/cell-phone-directory/mobile-phone-shops-cannock cheap european travel tickets [url=http://uhas.eu/cell-phone-reviews/what-is-the-phone-number-and-email-adress-to-cantact-the-fcc]parking at sky harbor travel[/url]
alicia klein tour one travel wallet http://uhas.eu/phone/best-smat-phone cheap air travel online [url=http://uhas.eu/mobile/word-mobile-problems]word mobile problems[/url]
travel channel website http://uhas.eu/mobile-phone/local-phone-companies travel jewelry pouches [url=http://uhas.eu/cell-phone-reviews/cell-phone-tazer-electrode]travel channel culebra[/url]

Anonymous said...

rite aid pharmacy homepage http://liposuction.rxpharm.in stroke and heart attack pharmacy [url=http://acne.rxpharm.in/how-to-get-rid-of-swelling-acne]how to get rid of swelling acne[/url]
recept pharmacy http://bath-salt.rxpharm.in/homemade-gift-in-a-jar community pharmacy slc ut 3900s [url=http://bath-salt.rxpharm.in/homemade-gift-for-boyfriend]creighton university school of pharmacy[/url]
wayne pharmacy http://fitness.rxpharm.in/fitness-plan-for-seniors lloyds pharmacy st paul mn [url=http://cellulite.rxpharm.in/cellulite-hilfe]cellulite hilfe[/url]
tupolo college of pharmacy http://ayurveda.rxpharm.in/entspannung-erholung-ayurveda-wellness-urlaub-exclusiv topic regarding pharmacy [url=http://facial.rxpharm.in/toning-facial-muscle]boots pharmacy uk[/url]
sb college of pharmacy http://cellulite.rxpharm.in/cellulite-hilfe boelling pharmacy herrington ks [url=http://warts.rxpharm.in/plantar-wart-duct-tape-cure]plantar wart duct tape cure[/url]
colorado pharmacy internships http://bath-salt.rxpharm.in/homemade-bath-salt-recipe brant pharmacy [url=http://homeopathy.rxpharm.in/homeopathy-arnica]massachusetts college of pharmacy and health sciences[/url]

Anonymous said...

pharmacy teshnician schools http://kqp.in/quit-smoking_smoking-mirrors-in-albany-new-york funded pharmacy postgraduate study [url=http://kqp.in/stop-smoking_counties-that-permit-smoking-in-ohio]counties that permit smoking in ohio[/url]
ppc pharmacy mcallen texas http://kqp.in/tramadol_tramadol-roomed-online canadian pharmacy viagra [url=http://kqp.in/viagra_viagra-postal-order]california pharmacy schools[/url]
ohio certified pharmacy tech http://kqp.in/quit-smoking_quit-smoking-benefits old time pharmacy soda fountain [url=http://kqp.in/soma_is-soma-addictive]is soma addictive[/url]
online pharmacy oxycontin 20mg http://kqp.in/article-syndrome_mmt-syndrome options in the bsps programs at ut college of pharmacy [url=http://kqp.in/zyban_zyban-birth-control-pill]richardson pharmacy wichita kansas[/url]
south carolina pharmacy association http://kqp.in/tea_apple-and-cinnamon-tea-cake natural weight loss pharmacy [url=http://kqp.in/smoking_african-smoking-pipes]african smoking pipes[/url]
new jersey pharmacy dispense laboratory http://kqp.in/syndrome_people-with-crouzons-syndrome pharmacy technician in new jersey [url=http://kqp.in/soma_discount-from-prescription-price-rx-soma]how to become a pharmacy technician[/url]

Anonymous said...

how is ict used in the travel industry http://motel.qrv.in/kingston-beach-motel greencard travel [url=http://hotel.qrv.in/atlantic-beach-hotel-san-juan]atlantic beach hotel san juan[/url]
holiday network international a premier travel network http://travel.qrv.in/aladdin-travel-cups europe travel group nw usa [url=http://maps.qrv.in/satelitte-maps-of-ohio]interline travel discount[/url]
gap travel insurance http://adventure.qrv.in/fincher-adventure alert special t travel [url=http://plane-tickets.qrv.in/rome-really-cheap-plane-tickets]rome really cheap plane tickets[/url]
travel sitz bath http://maps.qrv.in/maps-of-mt-everest-camps canada cheap travel [url=http://car-rental.qrv.in/myrtle-beach-international-airport-car-rental]travel to yellowstone national park[/url]
travel northern california http://plane-tickets.qrv.in/plane-tickets-to-beijing travel sente [url=http://maps.qrv.in]maps[/url]
us government travel and citizenship or visa http://airport.qrv.in/terminal-2-constructed-phoenix-sky-harbor-international-airport china tour travel htm [url=http://tourism.qrv.in/arrezo-italy-tourism]annual travel insurance cheap uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hello,we are happy to inform you about russian girls escorts staying now in Kuala Lumpur(just arrived).if you want to make a reservation,please send sms to +60124460864 (SMS ONLY) location for incall in bukit bintang,near BB plasa.if you need outcall please send me your adress,name and details etc price for 1 h 800 RM,2 h 1400 RM,for full night meeting is 3500 RM
fotos on site files http://mermaids.tv/ ,it is original and not photoshopeed,100% have a nice day Thanks and best regards,Nastia p.s.do not ask discounts,i never give you I am the REAL DEAL with REAL PICS so there will be NO REGRETS I will do my best to fulfill your fantasies and turn them in to reality!



escort in KL,malaysia escort,singapore escort,escort in asia,kuala lumpur sex

Anonymous said...

I've on all occasions liked things like sand clocks, lava lamps, and the like to kind of fair-minded spend time staring at it as a form of catharsis. In a way, it helps me with meditation, to relieve emphasis and just fantasize fro nothing. That's why since I was a kid, instead of dolls and cars I've always collected more of such pieces like sand clocks, lava lamps, dulcet boxes etc. So I was most enchanted when I found the[url=http://www.dealtoworld.com/goods-1260-2-Laser++LED+Light+Show+Laser+Top+Gyroscope+with+Music+Effects.html] 2-Laser + LED Inconsiderable Appear Laser Ace Gyroscope with Music Effects[/url] from DealtoWorld.com protection the Toys section. It's like a harmonious caddy, a spinning top, and a light show all rolled into one. Which is great relaxation! The gyroscope will whirl after round a minute. The laser light pretension with accompanying music makes this gyroscope a pretty unique bauble that my friends get also been most amused with.

My dogs are also nice-looking intrusive around the laser gyroscope I got from DealtoWorld.com. They evermore attend the gyroscope as it spins, although at first they kept barking at the laser light boast, and also because it produces music. But after they got worn it, they've stopped barking but virtuous watch over following the gyroscope whenever I start spinning it. Kids are also unbelievably amused alongside it. Sometimes it's good to maintain fun toys throughout the lineage so that you can pull out the toy on while the kids are being amused or playing with it while you live provide for viands or get changed. The gyroscope is unified such play with with this purpose.

The gyroscope I bought from DealtoWorld.com has a dragon as a intent plot on it, and produces a dainty exposition with red, downcast, and unskilled colours. Nick a look at the pictures I've uploaded of the gyroscope with laser joyful show. The music produced from the gyroscope is not that enormous but allowable adequacy to entertain any supplementary guest to the house. The gyroscope is red and black, making it look very coolth, and slightly masculine with that dragon imprint.

The music flare make clear gyroscope runs on 6 LR44 batteries, which are replaceable anyway. I've also acclimatized this gyroscope to their heels my girlfriend during our anniversary celebration. I did the cheesy terror of decorating the hostelry room with roses and when I led her in, I started up the gyroscope as affectionately so that the laser brighten clarify produces a dreamed-up effect. I also had some battery operated candles so all the sunrise effects created a slightly dreamt-up atmosphere. She loved it, at near the custom, to my relief. I also bought the candles from DealtoWorld.com. These days it seems to be my oversight shopping locality suitable all gifts and ideas in behalf of romanticist occasions.

Since Christmas is coming, this laser radiance make clear gyroscope can maybe be a momentous Christmas contribution in behalf of the toddler or methodical the favoured! Alternatively, the gyroscope can altogether be a polite summation to the traditional Christmas decorations. I can take it as given placing it adjoining the Christmas tree and maybe spinning it when guests succeed in the house. Looks like [url=http://www.dealtoworld.com]DealtoWorld.com[/url] is getting my function thus far again!

Anonymous said...

[url=http://geobloggers.org/2011/01/04/description-of-free-online-games/]free online games[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.kamagrashop.pl]viagra[/url], check up on my site. If you are interested in entourage, be aware [url=http://www.4uescort.de]huren[/url] or [url=http://www.escort4u.pl]ogloszenia towarzyskie[/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.freewebs.com/order-amitriptyline-10-mg-online-melbourne]amitriptyline 10 mg anxiety
[/url]purchase amitriptyline 25 mg online australia
amitriptyline 25 mg for fibromyalgia
london order amitriptyline 75 mg
Sydney purchase endep 10 mg
purchase amitriptyline

Anonymous said...

Hello. Facebook takes a [url=http://www.casinobonus.gd]no deposit[/url] stick on 888 casino grapple with: Facebook is expanding its efforts to mete out real-money gaming to millions of British users after announcing a sell with the online gambling firm 888 Holdings.And Bye.

Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.001casino.com/]online casinos[/url] coincide the latest [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com/]casino bonus[/url] free no deposit reward at the leading [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]redeem casino
[/url].

Anonymous said...

[url=http://buy-methylprednisolone.webspawner.com/]solu medrol a steroid
[/url] methylprednisolone acute bronchitis
depo medrol for cats allergies
purchasing Phocenta 16 mg

Anonymous said...

http://biaxin-buy.webs.com/ clarithromycin 250 mg
http://sustiva-efavirenz.webs.com/ buy Sustiva 200 mg
http://asacol-mesalamine.webs.com/ mesalamine 400 mg tablets
http://www.freewebs.com/pentasa-mesalamine/ pentasa 400 mg

Anonymous said...

It's awesome to pay a quick visit this site and reading the views of all friends regarding this paragraph, while I am also eager of getting know-how.

my site; firma reklamowa

Anonymous said...

Have you ever thought about why it is more difficult to have pregnant right after forty than after we were young, say within our early to 20s?
Remember that everyone is different, and if this new method of technique you just read about didn't work for you, then it's ok!
http://www.pregnancyhelper.in

Anonymous said...

High alcohol consumption can also cause infertility among men and women. If you are interested in how to get pregnant after tubal ligation, it is the place to go! However, one shouldn't consider that she cannot get pregnant on any other days of the menstrual cycle.
pregnancyhelper.in